Showing posts with label Merit Pay. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Merit Pay. Show all posts
Saturday, April 16, 2011
State Senate OKs bill tying teacher evaluations to layoffs
“State Senate OKs bill tying teacher evaluations to layoffs” by Molly Rosbach, The Associated Press The Seattle Times Published 4/12/11 Retrieved 4/16/11 Complete URL: http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/education/2014756842_education13.html Intended Audience: teachers, administrators, lawmakers Summary: The state Senate has given the go-ahead for a bill that proposes to put teachers who score the lowest on their performance evaluations at the front of the line for any impending layoffs. The bill was modified to include school principals in the layoffs as well. Opponents to the bill argue that instead of changing how teachers are laid off, they should be trying to avoid teacher layoffs altogether and focus on managing the teacher’s demands by decreasing class size, increasing planning time, and offering more student support services. Key Point: The Senate has approved a bill to order teacher layoffs by performance instead of seniority. Relevance: This is one of the first big steps in the shift to what will hopefully eventually become performance-based salaries and job security. I thought it extremely interesting that the opponents to this bill were never once reported to argue directly against preference by seniority. The old way of the exclusive, gentlemen’s-club, good-ol’-boys idea of job security is coming to an end.
Thursday, March 24, 2011
Spend Money Like it Matters
Article Author name(s): Frederick M. Hess
Title of article: Spend Money Like it Matters
Title of journal: Educational Leadership
Date of publication: December 2010/January 2011
Volume of the journal: 68
Issue number of the journal: 4
Article Page numbers: pp. 51-54
http://www.ascd.org/publications/educational-leadership/dec10/vol68/num04/Spend-Money-Like-It-Matters.aspx
Intended audience: Policy makers, administrators and teachers
Key Points: Instead of being used as a threat to measure good performance, merit based pay can be used in a smart way to attract, retain and reward great teachers. Just as dentists, engineers and babysitters are able to command higher pay according to results, teachers should also be able to make such commands. Using seniority and how many academic credits have been taken is not an accurate way to gauge a teacher’s value, nor is it effective to simply offer up bonuses for teachers whose students pass standardized tests. Rethinking pay can help make employees feel valued, make the teaching profession more attractive to potential entrants, and signal that teachers are being held in a professional regard.
“One-size-fits-all” pay scales are not good either, because they either mean we pay the most effective teachers too little, or the less effective teachers too much, as it’s a certainty that some teachers will and are more effective than others in any given area.
In order to better determine which teachers may qualify for extra merit pay schools must make comprehensive lists as to what skills, behaviors and results will earn a person increased pay. Aspects that may occur on the list could be scarcity of individuals in the labor market, annual evaluation by peers, professional observations, supervisor judgment, and so forth. The obsession with student test scores interest has been an unfortunate distraction.
In order to be successful in teaching students and making determinations as to the value of teachers, administrators need to look forward in how changes can be made, not backward. The test-based merit-pay scale moves backward in rewarding past performance (or at least their students’ performance) whereas offering up merit-based pay based off of knowledge, skill, and ongoing education is more a productive way to evaluate teachers and promote student learning and understanding.
Title of article: Spend Money Like it Matters
Title of journal: Educational Leadership
Date of publication: December 2010/January 2011
Volume of the journal: 68
Issue number of the journal: 4
Article Page numbers: pp. 51-54
http://www.ascd.org/publications/educational-leadership/dec10/vol68/num04/Spend-Money-Like-It-Matters.aspx
Intended audience: Policy makers, administrators and teachers
Key Points: Instead of being used as a threat to measure good performance, merit based pay can be used in a smart way to attract, retain and reward great teachers. Just as dentists, engineers and babysitters are able to command higher pay according to results, teachers should also be able to make such commands. Using seniority and how many academic credits have been taken is not an accurate way to gauge a teacher’s value, nor is it effective to simply offer up bonuses for teachers whose students pass standardized tests. Rethinking pay can help make employees feel valued, make the teaching profession more attractive to potential entrants, and signal that teachers are being held in a professional regard.
“One-size-fits-all” pay scales are not good either, because they either mean we pay the most effective teachers too little, or the less effective teachers too much, as it’s a certainty that some teachers will and are more effective than others in any given area.
In order to better determine which teachers may qualify for extra merit pay schools must make comprehensive lists as to what skills, behaviors and results will earn a person increased pay. Aspects that may occur on the list could be scarcity of individuals in the labor market, annual evaluation by peers, professional observations, supervisor judgment, and so forth. The obsession with student test scores interest has been an unfortunate distraction.
In order to be successful in teaching students and making determinations as to the value of teachers, administrators need to look forward in how changes can be made, not backward. The test-based merit-pay scale moves backward in rewarding past performance (or at least their students’ performance) whereas offering up merit-based pay based off of knowledge, skill, and ongoing education is more a productive way to evaluate teachers and promote student learning and understanding.
Wednesday, March 9, 2011
In Florida, Push to Link Teacher Pay to Student Performance
LIZETTE ALVAREZ
March 8, 2011
In Florida, Push to Link Teacher Pay to Student Performance
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/09/education/09florida.html?ref=education
New York Times
Summary: The Florida Legislature quickly set its sights on measures that would link the pay of new teachers to student performance and allow school boards to fire teachers more easily for mediocre results.
The far-reaching bills in the House and Senate would shake up a system of pay and tenure in Florida that has existed for decades and would position Florida as a leader among those states taking on teachers’ unions. Supporters say it will make it easier to reward and promote the state’s best teachers, not by their longevity, but by their work in the classroom. This, they say, will ensure that the lowest-performing schools can lure more effective teachers.
Intended Audience: General Public
Key Points: 1) Contrary to education experts who blame poverty for low performance, this bill places the sole measure of performance on teachers.
2) New teachers will be subject to one year contracts. They will also be eligible for merit pay increases.
Relevance: Why am I doing this again?
March 8, 2011
In Florida, Push to Link Teacher Pay to Student Performance
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/09/education/09florida.html?ref=education
New York Times
Summary: The Florida Legislature quickly set its sights on measures that would link the pay of new teachers to student performance and allow school boards to fire teachers more easily for mediocre results.
The far-reaching bills in the House and Senate would shake up a system of pay and tenure in Florida that has existed for decades and would position Florida as a leader among those states taking on teachers’ unions. Supporters say it will make it easier to reward and promote the state’s best teachers, not by their longevity, but by their work in the classroom. This, they say, will ensure that the lowest-performing schools can lure more effective teachers.
Intended Audience: General Public
Key Points: 1) Contrary to education experts who blame poverty for low performance, this bill places the sole measure of performance on teachers.
2) New teachers will be subject to one year contracts. They will also be eligible for merit pay increases.
Relevance: Why am I doing this again?
Monday, February 7, 2011
Plan to Grade Parents Flunks Out
Article Author name(s): Lisa Ann Williamson
Title of article: Plan to Grade Parents Flunks Out
Title of journal: Teaching Tolerance
Date of publication: January 28, 2011
Volume of the journal: Spring 2011
Issue number of the journal: Thirty nine
Summary: Florida representative Kellie Stargel suggest plan that allows teachers to grade parents on how well children are rested, fed and on time to class with completed assignments. Grading scale is: “satisfactory -> unsatisfactory” -> needs improvement”.
Topic: Argues that just as teachers are graded by parents, administration and the outcomes of NCLB/ standardized testing, parents should be graded as well for the amount of effort they put in to securing their children’s education. Many educators disagree with this position saying that while the idea is highly entertaining, it will lead to nothing but great battles between parent and teachers, at the sacrifice if the student. Read the posted comments for more argument.
Introduction: Author argues that in the educational system, we have student, teacher and administration accountability and best practices/ standards, yet this is a system where parents have zero accountability for the success of their own children. Proposes additional grading system for parents.
Intended audience: Educators
Key Points: While parents have greatest effect on children’s success, it is not practical to grade parenting skills as it would result in extreme tension between educators and parents, at the expense of the students.
Relevance: At the very least this article proves the point as to how preposterous it is, then, to grade teachers on student’s success. If parents are not held responsible for their own children’s learning (or at least be encouraging of the process and goals), and they are the ones who are most influential upon students, than under what reasoning are educators expected to carry the full burden of their success?
http://www.tolerance.org/blog/plan-grade-parents-flunks-out
Title of article: Plan to Grade Parents Flunks Out
Title of journal: Teaching Tolerance
Date of publication: January 28, 2011
Volume of the journal: Spring 2011
Issue number of the journal: Thirty nine
Summary: Florida representative Kellie Stargel suggest plan that allows teachers to grade parents on how well children are rested, fed and on time to class with completed assignments. Grading scale is: “satisfactory -> unsatisfactory” -> needs improvement”.
Topic: Argues that just as teachers are graded by parents, administration and the outcomes of NCLB/ standardized testing, parents should be graded as well for the amount of effort they put in to securing their children’s education. Many educators disagree with this position saying that while the idea is highly entertaining, it will lead to nothing but great battles between parent and teachers, at the sacrifice if the student. Read the posted comments for more argument.
Introduction: Author argues that in the educational system, we have student, teacher and administration accountability and best practices/ standards, yet this is a system where parents have zero accountability for the success of their own children. Proposes additional grading system for parents.
Intended audience: Educators
Key Points: While parents have greatest effect on children’s success, it is not practical to grade parenting skills as it would result in extreme tension between educators and parents, at the expense of the students.
Relevance: At the very least this article proves the point as to how preposterous it is, then, to grade teachers on student’s success. If parents are not held responsible for their own children’s learning (or at least be encouraging of the process and goals), and they are the ones who are most influential upon students, than under what reasoning are educators expected to carry the full burden of their success?
http://www.tolerance.org/blog/plan-grade-parents-flunks-out
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)